Many ways to fall short of perfection

Trooping the Colour June 2013The molecules in a crystal are in a regular arrangement, in which ideally they are all in identical positions, like soldiers in a perfectly ordered parade. And crystals have many useful properties, they are the best conductors of electricity. But crystals are rarely perfect, and these imperfect crystals may have higher resistance to electricity.

There are a number of ways for a crystal to be imperfect, just as there a number of ways for a parade of soldiers to fail to coordinate. The spacing between successive lines of soldiers could vary between one line and the next, individual soldiers could fall out of line, some soldiers could be marching in slightly the wrong direction, etc.

So, which one of these many ways for crystals to fall short of perfection, is what effects crystals’ conductivity? I don’t think we know, but it could be important. And in science, like in most things where you need to get things done, people do what they can do; what is possible. In experiments on most crystals, the experimental scientists rely on X-ray diffraction to look for imperfections in crystals. X-ray diffraction can measure if lines of molecules are not uniformly spaced, and if individual molecules are out of line, but often can’t see if molecules are pointing the wrong way.

In contrast, computer simulators often study which directions molecules point. So different types of scientists are studying different breakdowns of the regular ordering of molecules in crystals, and I don’t think either type of scientist really knows which breakdown really controls properties such as electrical conductivity. I think this is because calculating conductivity in computer simulation is very hard, and our understanding of how to relate what X-rays are telling us, to conductivity, is still a work in progress.

We probably need improvements in experimental and computer simulation methods,  to make progress, but closing the gap between how experimental scientists and computer simulators see crystals could also help.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s